
Former Senior Research Fellow, Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies (BIDS)
In my previous article, I proposed a three-zone minimum wage structure of Tk 15,250, Tk 14,000 and Tk 13,125 as a fairer and more economically sustainable alternative to the proposed demand for a uniform minimum wage of Tk 32,000. The proposal has generated an important question: If China and Indonesia can afford to pay higher wages to their garment workers, why Bangladesh cannot do the same?
The answer lies in a fundamental difference that is often overlooked in the ongoing minimum wage debate: Bangladesh does not compete with its rivals on a level playing field. The cost of labour is only one component of the total cost of production. Even before wages are paid, Bangladesh already pays more to reach the buyer.
There are ten critical considerations that the Minimum Wage Board should take into account before reaching its decision.
- The Absence of a Deep-Sea Port in Bangladesh-This is Our Biggest Disadvantage
One of Bangladesh’s most significant competitive disadvantages is its limited maritime infrastructure, particularly the absence of a fully operational deep-sea port capable of accommodating large mother vessels.
China enjoys the advantage of world-class deep-water ports such as Shanghai, Shenzhen and Ningbo, which allow large container vessels to load and discharge cargo directly. Indonesia also benefits from major maritime gateways, including Jakarta and Surabaya.
Bangladesh, by contrast, remains heavily dependent on the Port of Chattogram, whose navigational limitations prevent the direct berthing of the largest ocean-going container vessels. Chattogram port is shallow. It cannot take mother vessels. Consequently, a substantial proportion of Bangladesh’s export containers must first be transported by smaller feeder vessels to major transshipment hubs such as Singapore or Port Klang in Malaysia. Containers are unloaded there, handled again and transferred to larger mother vessels bound for Europe and North America.
This transshipment arrangement entails additional handling charges, port fees, waiting periods and logistical risks. Every additional transfer creates another opportunity for delay, congestion or missed vessel connections.
China loads only once and sails. Bangladesh loads twice to reach the same buyer. The contrast is striking: while a container from China can often be loaded directly onto a large vessel for its overseas destination, a container from Bangladesh may have to undergo an additional journey and another round of handling before beginning its principal ocean voyage.
Bangladesh is, in effect, paying an additional logistical price simply to reach the same international market.
- Longer Shipping Time: A Serious Disadvantage in a Time-Sensitive Market
In the international garment trade, competitiveness is determined not only by price but also by the ability to deliver the right product at the right time.
Because of its dependence on feeder vessels and transshipment arrangements, our time is always longer. Indicatively, ocean transit from Bangladesh to the United States may take approximately 25–42 days, compared with around 14–30 days from China, depending on the destination, shipping route and prevailing conditions. Bangladesh to Europe is also longer, for the same reason- feeder to Singapore/Port Klang first, then long voyage via Suez.
A buyer who needs goods for Christmas or Summer season cannot wait 2-3 weeks extra. If Bangladesh is late, buyer cancels or shifts order to Vietnam/Indonesia where delivery is faster.
The proposed Matarbari Deep Sea Port could eventually help address some of these structural constraints. However, until it becomes fully operational and is supported by efficient connecting infrastructure and shipping services, Bangladesh will always be at this disadvantage.
- Escalating Shipping Costs: Bangladesh Pay More
The financial consequences of Bangladesh’s shipping disadvantages are equally serious. Because we pay feeder + mother vessel + double port charges, freight spikes hit us hardest.
In recent months, freight from Chattogram to USA jumped from $4,500 per container to more than $11,000. In October 2026, a 20-foot container from Chattogram to New York was quoted at up to $11,800, and a 40-foot at up to $12,900. During the same period, the corresponding indicative rates from Chattogram to Hamburg or Rotterdam were approximately USD 3,000 and USD 4,586, respectively for 40-foot.
These figures illustrate the substantial geographical and logistical cost differences confronting Bangladeshi exporters. Depending on container size and the quotation, shipping to the United States can cost approximately three to four times as much as shipping to major European destinations. Our competitors China and Indonesia do not bear the same logistical and operational cost burden that weighs heavily on Bangladeshi exporters.
A fundamental economic reality must be recognised here: when transportation costs rise sharply, international buyers do not pay the additional cost. The added expense is squeezed out of the factories and the workers’ wages.
The cost of shipping is therefore not merely a transportation issue; it is an integral component of the wage and employment debate.
- Bangladesh Imports Almost Everything, Competitors Do Not
Another major disadvantage confronting Bangladesh is its continued dependence on imported raw materials and intermediate inputs.
China makes its own fabric, yarn, buttons, zippers, and machinery. Indonesia, too, has a more established domestic textile base. By contrast, Bangladesh must import 80%+ of its woven fabric, chemicals, and accessories. These imports involve additional expenses, including customs duties where applicable, port handling charges, transportation costs, banking fees and financing costs.
Thus, Bangladesh bears costs at both ends of the production process: first, when importing essential inputs, and again when exporting finished garments. Every delay at Chattogram Port carries an additional cost, and every day lost to feeder-vessel delays further increases the burden.
Countries with more integrated domestic supply chains enjoy a considerable advantage because they can procure a larger proportion of their inputs locally, reduce delivery uncertainty and respond more quickly to changing buyer requirements.
- Energy Insecurity, Expensive Finance and Extended Production Lead Times
The competitiveness of an export-oriented industry depends on more than the availability of workers and machinery. Reliable energy, affordable financing and predictable production schedules are equally indispensable. Unfortunately, Bangladeshi manufacturers continue to face considerable difficulties in these areas.
Gas and electricity supply is uncertain. Bank interest in Bangladesh is far higher than in China, Vietnam, or Indonesia. Working capital for 90-120 days of import-to-export cycle costs more here. Because of transshipment + port congestion, lead time is 2-3 weeks longer.
International buyers, however, increasingly demand shorter lead times, greater flexibility and reliable delivery commitments. A manufacturer that cannot meet these requirements may lose orders even if its direct production costs are relatively low.
Bangladesh must therefore recognise that its competitiveness is determined by the cumulative cost of production, financing, energy and logistics—not simply by the wage paid to an individual worker.
- Cheap Labour Is Our ONLY Advantage Left- If We Lose It, We Lose Everything
Let us examine the competitive position of Bangladesh more objectively.
China has deep sea ports, full supply chain, technology, fast delivery, cheap finance. Indonesia has deep sea ports, raw materials, faster delivery. Vietnam has deep sea ports, FDI, technology, stable energy.
What, then, are we competing with? No deep-sea port, limited domestic sourcing of fabrics and raw materials, sluggish shipping connections, expensive freight, high bank interest rates, gas shortages, congested ports and lead times that put us at a disadvantage in an increasingly time-sensitive global market.
Against this background, we have only one advantage left: cheap labour. If we take away that one advantage by raising wages to Tk 32,000- then why will a buyer come to Bangladesh? The buyer’s decision is ultimately commercial. Orders will gravitate towards countries that can offer the most attractive combination of price, quality, reliability and delivery performance.
If Bangladesh increases workers’ salary substantially without addressing its underlying structural disadvantages, it risks weakening its competitive position. The consequences could be serious: declining orders, reduced factory utilisation, pressure on profit margins, business closures and, ultimately, employment losses.
Why would buyers continue to place orders in Bangladesh when China, Indonesia and Vietnam can offer better logistics, cheaper shipping and faster delivery-even while paying workers higher wages? If this competitive gap persists, Bangladeshi factories could lose orders, shut down and leave thousands of workers without jobs within the next one or two years.
The challenge is not simply to increase wages; it is to increase wages in a manner consistent with the long-term survival and competitiveness of the industry.
- Electricity Shortages and Generator Dependence: The Hidden Cost of Production
Energy insecurity represents another important component of Bangladesh’s industrial cost disadvantage. In an export-oriented manufacturing industry, uninterrupted electricity is essential. Production schedules are tightly linked to delivery commitments, and even relatively short interruptions can disrupt workflow, reduce productivity and increase operating expenses.
China, Indonesia, Vietnam have stable power. Their factories run on grid electricity, 24 hours, without interruption. Bangladeshi factories in industrial areas such as Dhaka, Gazipur, Narayanganj and Chattogram have faced challenges associated with load-shedding, voltage fluctuations and inadequate gas supplies.
When grid electricity becomes unreliable, factories are forced to rely on backup generators, adding substantially to production costs through fuel, equipment, maintenance and operating expenses. Frequent switching between grid and generator power also disrupts production and wastes valuable working time. In many factories, generator electricity costs two to three times more than grid power. Consequently, a shirt manufactured in China may benefit from cheaper grid electricity, while the same shirt made in Bangladesh carries the added burden of expensive generator power.
Unless Bangladesh improves the reliability and affordability of industrial energy, its manufacturers will continue to bear an additional cost that cannot be eliminated merely through wage negotiations.
- A Three-Zone Wage Structure Could Help Decentralise Industry and Transform Dhaka
Dhaka has become excessively concentrated with garment factories and other labour-intensive industries. This concentration has intensified pressure on land, housing, transportation, utilities and urban services. Because wages are the same everywhere, factories have no reason to leave Dhaka.
Factories remain concentrated around Dhaka partly because the existing wage structure offers little incentive to relocate. A proposed three-zone system-higher wages of Tk 15,250 in Dhaka and Chattogram, Tk. 14,000 to intermediate industrial locations, and Tk 13,125 in lower-cost regions-could encourage investment in areas such as Rangpur, Dinajpur, Rajshahi, Barisal and Khulna, where land and rents are cheaper. This would create jobs closer to workers’ homes, reduce migration to major cities and lower their living and relocation costs. For manufacturers, lower land prices, factory rentals and other operating expenses could improve the economics of establishing production facilities outside Dhaka.
Over time, a more balanced geographical distribution of industries could help reduce the excessive concentration of low-value, labour-intensive manufacturing in the capital.
A gradual shift towards higher-value industries-including technology, AI, software, finance, design and corporate services-could allow Dhaka to evolve into a centre of higher-productivity economic activity. The aim is not to weaken Dhaka’s industrial base, but to promote balanced regional industrialisation through zone-based wages and infrastructure investment.
This follows a development pathway seen in many industrialising economies: relocating labour-intensive manufacturing to lower-cost regions while transforming major cities into hubs for higher-value industries and services. This is how every developed country did it. First, they moved low-wage factories out of the capital, then they brought high-income industries into the capital.
- Air Shipment Cost Is Also Very High – Compared to China and Indonesia
When sea shipment is late-because of feeder delay, port congestion, or Red Sea crisis -the factory has no choice. It must send goods by air to meet buyer’s deadline. And air from Bangladesh is extremely expensive.
Dhaka’s Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport is described by freight forwarders as one of the most expensive cargo airports in the world, even more expensive than Singapore. Exporters pay high terminal handling charge, high security scanning charge to CAAB, plus VAT and ground handling surcharge.
Indicative freight rates reported for different destinations illustrate the scale of the problem:
– Dhaka to Europe: Around $3.00 – $3.50 per kg in normal time, $6.30 – $6.50 per kg in crisis.
– Dhaka to USA: Around $4.50 per kg in normal time, $7.50 – $8.00 per kg in crisis.
– Delhi / Kolkata to Europe: Around $1.20 – $2.00 per kg – almost half of Dhaka.
These differences have reportedly encouraged some buyers and freight operators to explore alternative routing arrangements for Bangladeshi garments, including transportation by road to Delhi airport or by sea to Colombo before onward air shipment. Even after accounting for additional transportation expenses, such alternatives may sometimes offer financial savings.
That is why many buyers now take Bangladeshi garments by truck to Delhi airport, or by sea to Colombo airport, just to save $0.40 – $1.00 per kg-even after paying truck cost. Dhaka is that expensive.
China and Indonesia do not have this problem. They have many direct cargo flights, many airlines competing, large cargo terminals, low handling charges. Their air freight is cheaper and faster.
Bangladesh pays twice for its logistical shortcomings: first we pay high sea freight because we have no deep-sea port, then when sea is late, we pay very high air freight because Dhaka airport is expensive and congested.
- Keeping Industry Competitive: Allowing Supply and Demand to Shape Wages
This brings us to the central issue of the minimum wage debate.
Wages must be fair, workers must be able to maintain a decent standard of living, and their contribution to the country’s export success must be properly recognised. There should be no disagreement about these fundamental principles. However, wage policy must also take account of the economic conditions under which industries operate and the capacity of employers to sustain employment.
A distinction needs to be made between wage increases supported by rising productivity, expanding demand for labour and improved industrial performance, and increases imposed without sufficient consideration of the prevailing economic environment.
When unemployment rate is low – when factories are competing for workers, when there are more jobs than workers – then wages will go up by themselves. Workers will get higher pay because factories must pay more to attract them. That is natural, healthy, sustainable wage growth. That is how China, Vietnam, and Korea grew.
Bangladesh, however, faces a different economic reality. With unemployment and underemployment persisting and factories already struggling with high shipping, energy and air-freight costs, a uniform wage increase to Tk 32,000, without adequate consideration of productivity, employment conditions, regional cost differences and international competitiveness, could place many vulnerable factories under severe financial strain. Some may be forced to scale down or shut down, while international buyers could shift orders to lower-cost, more efficient competitors such as Indonesia and Vietnam. The consequences would extend beyond factory owners to the very workers the wage increase is intended to benefit, through lost jobs and rising unemployment.
A minimum wage policy should therefore balance three essential objectives: protecting workers’ livelihoods, sustaining industrial employment and preserving Bangladesh’s competitiveness in international markets.
Conclusion: Do Not Kill the Goose That Lays the Golden Egg
Bangladesh’s RMG sector is far more than an export-oriented manufacturing sector. It employs 4 million workers, earns 80%+ of export earnings, and supports 10% of GDP. It survived because our total landed cost was competitive, even with low wages.
Its success has been built on a combination of entrepreneurial initiative, international market access, a large workforce and relatively competitive production costs. If we raise wages to a level that makes our landed cost higher than China and Indonesia, buyers will leave. Not slowly – quickly. As we saw in the Philippines, 50,000 garment jobs were lost in 3 years when costs became uncompetitive.
That is why I proposed a 3-Zone system with 5% yearly increment on Basic only. It gives workers a real increase, without making Bangladesh lose the shipping war. Let us be fair to workers, but let us also be honest about Bangladesh’s disadvantages. A wage we cannot afford will not help workers – it will make them jobless.
Bangladesh must simultaneously invest in deep-sea port infrastructure, improve the efficiency of Chattogram port, reduce shipping and air freight costs, strengthen domestic backward linkages, ensure reliable energy supplies and make industrial financing more affordable.
The Minimum Wage Board must therefore look beyond the nominal wage figure. It must consider the entire economic environment in which Bangladeshi manufacturers compete. I urge the 8th Minimum Wage Board to consider not only the wage, but the full cost of doing business in Bangladesh.
We must be fair to our workers, but we must also be realistic about the economic challenges confronting our industries. A wage policy that overlooks the cost of competitiveness may ultimately undermine the very employment and livelihoods it seeks to protect.

